The Montreal Screwjob: A Betrayal that Rocked the Industry

Ca 2025

4 min read

·

29-12-2024

7

0

Share

The Montreal Screwjob. The mere mention of the phrase sends shivers down the spines of professional wrestling fans, even decades later. It's a moment etched in wrestling history not for its athletic prowess, but for its raw, unscripted drama and the profound betrayal at its heart. This event, which took place at Survivor Series 1997, irrevocably altered the landscape of professional wrestling, leaving a legacy of controversy and questioning the very nature of the business. This article will delve into the intricacies of the Screwjob, examining its causes, consequences, and lasting impact on the wrestling world. We will draw upon accounts and analysis found in various sources, including scholarly work on the industry (though specific Sciencedirect articles directly addressing this specific event are limited; the focus will be on the broader context and implications which can be linked to broader wrestling literature readily available).

The Setup: Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels – A Clash of Titans

The late 1990s saw a fierce rivalry between Bret "Hitman" Hart, the WWF Champion at the time, and Shawn Michaels, a rising star known for his arrogance and in-ring brilliance. Hart, a master technician and a cornerstone of the WWF (World Wrestling Federation, now WWE), was a Canadian hero who embodied the company's traditional values. Michaels, on the other hand, represented a newer, more flamboyant style. Their clash was not just a battle of wrestling styles; it was a clash of personalities and philosophies.

Hart's contract was nearing its end, and he had reached an agreement with the WWF's competitor, WCW (World Championship Wrestling). However, he refused to lose the WWF Championship to Michaels on American soil, fearing that losing to Michaels in his home country would damage his credibility with his Canadian fanbase and hurt his planned WCW debut. This is a key point often overlooked – the narrative wasn’t simply about "losing the belt"; it was about how and where he lost it, impacting his future career prospects.

The Night of Betrayal: Survivor Series 1997

The planned finish of the match saw Hart submitting to Michaels, thus dropping the championship in a clean fashion. However, Vince McMahon, the owner of the WWF, orchestrated a "screwjob" – a pre-arranged outcome unbeknownst to Hart. Without Hart's knowledge or consent, referee Earl Hebner was instructed to call for the bell as Michaels applied his sharpshooter submission hold even though Hart hadn't submitted.

This blatant disregard for Hart's professional integrity, his carefully negotiated terms, and his career trajectory sent shockwaves through the industry. The live audience erupted in a mix of confusion and anger. Hart was furious, spitting at McMahon, and physically confronting Michaels. The planned post-match celebration was replaced with chaos and raw emotion. The event was captured on camera and the footage became instantly infamous.

The Fallout: A Legacy of Resentment and Controversy

The Montreal Screwjob irrevocably damaged relationships within the WWF. Hart's departure to WCW was acrimonious, and the event became a defining moment in the "Monday Night Wars," the intense ratings battle between the WWF and WCW. The betrayal fueled countless debates about loyalty, trust, and the ethical considerations within professional wrestling.

The event also sparked discussions surrounding the nature of kayfabe – the theatrical presentation of wrestling where predetermined outcomes are presented as real-time competitions. The screwjob exposed the artifice to a degree never before seen on a major scale, shattering the illusion for many fans. It also emphasized the power dynamics within the business, highlighting the absolute authority of the promoter, even at the expense of long-standing wrestler relationships and contracts.

Long-Term Impacts: A Watershed Moment in Wrestling History

The Montreal Screwjob's impact extends far beyond the immediate aftermath. It altered the industry's power dynamics, prompting wrestlers to be more vigilant about protecting their own interests and contractual agreements. It led to greater scrutiny of backstage dealings and contractual negotiations, forcing more transparency (though not necessarily complete transparency).

The event also served as a pivotal point in the evolution of professional wrestling. The era of meticulously planned storylines and carefully crafted character arcs, while always present to varying degrees, became more prominent, showing how a single unscripted moment could eclipse even the most ambitious narratives.

Analysis and Further Considerations:

While sources like Sciencedirect may not explicitly analyze the Montreal Screwjob as a discrete case study, research on organizational behavior, conflict resolution, and contract law can offer insightful parallels. The incident highlights the challenges of maintaining trust and cooperation in a highly competitive and intensely personal environment.

The Screwjob also raises questions about the ethical responsibilities of employers towards their employees. McMahon's actions, while technically within the legal parameters of the contract (a point constantly debated by fans and experts), were undeniably unethical, causing substantial emotional and reputational damage to Hart.

Conclusion:

The Montreal Screwjob remains a watershed moment in professional wrestling history. It was more than just a wrestling match; it was a raw, emotional display of betrayal that exposed the underbelly of the business, challenging the lines between performance and reality, and leaving an enduring legacy of controversy and discussion. While the event shattered trust and created lasting rifts, it also spurred changes within the industry, highlighting the importance of transparency, contract negotiation and the need to treat professional wrestlers not just as performers, but as valuable employees with their own distinct rights and professional goals. The Montreal Screwjob continues to be studied and debated, ensuring that its impact on the wrestling world will remain relevant for generations to come.